Football League
1905/06 Members◄ 1906/07 Members ►1907/08 Members
| Club | Division | Finishing Position | FA Cup |
| Aston Villa | First Division | 5th | 2nd Round |
| Birmingham | First Division | 9th | 1st Round |
| Blackburn Rovers | First Division | 12th | 2nd Round |
| Bolton Wanderers | First Division | 6th | 3rd Round |
| Bristol City | First Division | 2nd - Runners Up | 2nd Round |
| Bury | First Division | 16th | 3rd Round |
| Derby County | First Division | ▼19th - Relegated | 3rd Round |
| Everton | First Division | 3rd | Runners Up |
| Liverpool | First Division | 15th | Quarter Finals |
| Manchester City | First Division | 17th | 1st Round |
| Manchester United | First Division | 8th | 1st Round |
| Middlesbrough | First Division | 11th | 2nd Round |
| Newcastle United | First Division | 1st - Champions | 1st Round |
| Notts County | First Division | 18th | Quarter Finals |
| Preston North End | First Division | 14th | 1st Round |
| Sheffield United | First Division | 4th | 1st Round |
| Sheffield Wednesday | First Division | 13th | Winners |
| Stoke | First Division | ▼20th - Relegated | 1st Round |
| Sunderland | First Division | 10th | 3rd Round |
| Woolwich Arsenal | First Division | 7th | Semi Finals |
-
| Club | Division | Finishing Position | FA Cup |
| Barnsley | Second Division | 8th | Quarter Finals |
| Blackpool | Second Division | 13th | 1st Round |
| Bradford City | Second Division | 5th | 3rd Round |
| Burnley | Second Division | 7th | 1st Round |
| Burslem Port Vale | Second Division | ▼16th - Resigned | 2nd Round |
| Burton United | Second Division | ▼20th - Not Re Elected | 1st Round |
| Chelsea | Second Division | ▲2nd - Promoted | 1st Round |
| Chesterfield Town | Second Division | 18th - Re Elected | 1st Round |
| Clapton Orient | Second Division | 17th | Did Not Enter |
| Gainsborough Trinity | Second Division | 14th | 1st Round |
| Glossop | Second Division | 15th | 1st Round |
| Grimsby Town | Second Division | 11th | 1st Round |
| Hull City | Second Division | 9th | 1st Round |
| Leeds City | Second Division | 10th | 1st Round |
| Leicester Fosse | Second Division | 3rd | 1st Round |
| Lincoln City | Second Division | 19th - Re Elected | 2nd Round |
| Nottingham Forest | Second Division | ▲1st - Promoted | 1st Round |
| Stockport County | Second Division | 12th | 1st Round |
| West Bromwich Albion | Second Division | 4th | Semi Finals |
| Wolverhampton Wanderers | Second Division | 6th | 1st Round |
Voting for League Membership
| Six non-league clubs challenged the three Second Division sides who needed to seek re-election in the vote for League membership. Burslem Port Vale Resigned from the League after the vote so Oldham Athletic were Elected as highest team not to be originally Elected to the League. | ||
| Votes | Club | End Result |
| 28 | Fulham | ▲Elected to the League |
| 28 | Lincoln City | Re Elected to the League |
| 23 | Chesterfield Town | Re Elected to the League |
| 17 | Oldham Athletic | ▲Elected to the League |
| 11 | Bradford Park Avenue | Not Elected to the League |
| 7 | Burton United | ▼Not Re Elected to the League |
| 0 | Rotherham Town | Not Elected to the League |
| 0 | Salford United | Not Elected to the League |
| 0 | Wigan Town | Not Elected to the League |
1905/06 Members◄ 1906/07 Members ►1907/08 Members